Skip to content

Free resource Updated

The 12-point local visibility check

Why your business isn't showing up, and how to tell which part is broken.

No email required. No call required. Score yourself, fix what's red, ignore the rest.

On this page

How to score

Give each item 2 if it's fully sorted, 1 if it's partly there, 0 if it isn't. Twenty-four points available.

Part 1 Points 1 to 5

The map pack

This is the block of three businesses with the map above them. For most local service businesses it's where the majority of the calls come from, and it's a completely separate ranking system from the blue links below it.

Your primary category is the right one

Of the 187 factors Whitespark's 2026 study scored, primary category came out number one for the map pack. Not in the top ten. Number one.

Most businesses pick something close enough and never revisit it. "Contractor" instead of "Roofing contractor". "Plumber" instead of "Drainage service". Go look at the top three results for the search you want to win and check what they've chosen.

Score 0 if you can't remember what you picked, or you picked it in 2019.

Score for check 1: Your primary category is the right one

Your business name matches your signage

Keywords in the business title is the third strongest factor in that same study, which is why so many businesses stuff them in. It also violates Google's guidelines and gets profiles suspended.

The honest version: use your real name. If your real name happens to contain what you do, that's a genuine advantage and you should use it consistently everywhere.

Score 0 if your profile says "Mike's Plumbing | Emergency Plumber Denver | 24/7 Drain Repair" and your van says "Mike's Plumbing".

Score for check 2: Your business name matches your signage

Your hours are set, and they're accurate

"Business is open at the time of search" entered the top five map-pack factors for the first time in 2026. It came from nowhere. If you're closed when someone searches, you can be pushed out of a pack you'd otherwise rank in.

Check holiday hours too. A profile that says you're open on a public holiday when you're not generates a bad review, and a profile that says closed when you're open costs you the call.

Score 0 if you have no hours set, or you've never touched holiday hours.

Score for check 3: Your hours are set, and they're accurate

Your map pin is in the right place

Sounds trivial. It's the tenth strongest map-pack factor. Drag it and check. Pins drift, especially for businesses in industrial parks, strip malls, or anywhere with a shared address.

Score 0 if you've never looked.

Score for check 4: Your map pin is in the right place

Your services are filled in

"Keywords in GBP services" jumped 75 places in the 2026 rankings, from 110th to 35th. That's one of the biggest single moves in the whole dataset, and almost nobody has filled this section in.

It takes twenty minutes. List every service you actually offer, using the words a customer would use rather than the words the trade uses.

Score 0 if the services section is empty or has three generic entries.

Score for check 5: Your services are filled in

Part 2 Points 6 to 8

Reviews

You're above 4.5 stars

31% of consumers now say they will only consider a business at 4.5 or above. A year earlier that number was 17%. 68% won't go below 4.0.

If you're sitting at 4.3, you're being filtered out by roughly a third of people before they've read a word.

Score 0 if you're below 4.0. Score 1 if you're between 4.0 and 4.5.

Score for check 6: You're above 4.5 stars

You reply to reviews within a week, in your own words

89% of consumers expect a response. 19% now expect it the same day, up from 6% a year ago. 81% expect it within a week.

Here's the part that matters more: 50% of consumers react negatively to a generic response. Which means the obvious fix, running replies through AI, actively works against you. Google also lists AI-generated profile content as a suspension risk in its own right.

Write four sentences yourself. It takes less time than reading this paragraph.

Score 0 if you don't reply, or you reply with the same three lines every time.

Score for check 7: You reply to reviews within a week, in your own words

You're asking for reviews systematically

Not "sometimes when a job goes well". A repeatable step at the end of every job, with a direct link, sent the same day.

Review quantity is the ninth strongest map-pack factor and consumers now consult an average of six review sites before deciding. Volume compounds and it's the one input entirely within your control.

Score 0 if it's ad hoc.

Score for check 8: You're asking for reviews systematically

Part 3 Points 9 to 11

Your website

You have a separate page for each service

The strongest factor for local organic rankings, ahead of links, ahead of everything. One page listing eight services will lose to eight pages.

Score 0 if you have a services page. Score 2 if you have a page per service, each written properly.

Score for check 9: You have a separate page for each service

Your site loads in under three seconds on a phone

Test it on actual mobile data, not your office wifi. Most local business sites are carrying a page of unoptimised photos and four tracking scripts nobody remembers installing.

Score 0 if you haven't tested it.

Score for check 10: Your site loads in under three seconds on a phone

Your name, address and phone number are identical everywhere

Your site, your Google profile, Facebook, Yelp, industry directories, old listings you forgot about. Every variation is a small vote against you being one consistent business.

This one is boring and it has become more important, not less. Three of the top five factors for showing up in AI answers are citation-related.

Score 0 if you've changed address or number in the last three years and haven't done a sweep.

Score for check 11: Your name, address and phone number are identical everywhere

Part 4 Point 12

AI

You've actually checked what AI says about you

Open ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, and Perplexity. Ask each one for the best [your service] in [your town]. Do it three times, because the answers vary run to run.

Are you named? Is anything it says about you wrong?

45% of consumers now use AI tools to find local businesses, up from 6% a year ago. It's the third most-used tool for local recommendations, ahead of Yelp.

Score 0 if you've never looked.

Score for check 12: You've actually checked what AI says about you

What your score means

20 to 24

Your foundations are solid. Your problem is competition or conversion, not visibility. Don't buy SEO, look at what happens after the phone rings.

13 to 19

Normal. Two or three fixes from the red items above will move more than any retainer would in the same period. Do those first, then reassess.

7 to 12

There's real money sitting in the gaps. Most of it is free to fix and takes a weekend.

0 to 6

Nothing else is worth spending on until this is sorted. Paid ads into a broken foundation is just a faster way to lose money.

What nobody should be selling you

Since you'll probably get a cold email about this within the week.

Guaranteed rankings.
Nobody controls Google. Anyone guaranteeing a position is either lying or planning to rank you for a phrase nobody searches, then show you a screenshot of it.
An llms.txt file.
Google's Gary Illyes said on the record in July 2025 that Google does not use llms.txt and has no plans to. Independent testing across roughly 300,000 domains found no measurable effect. It is currently the single clearest sign you're being sold nonsense.
"AI schema" or special markup for AI.
Google's own documentation says: "There's also no special schema.org structured data that you need to add."
Content chunked or rewritten for LLMs.
Also explicitly addressed in Google's docs. Their systems handle multiple topics on a page.
Guaranteed ChatGPT citations.
Ask the same question ten times and you'll get different answers. Anyone showing you a single screenshot as proof either doesn't know that or is counting on you not knowing.
"Your Google listing is about to expire."
It won't. That call is a scam and it has been for a decade.
Anything sold to you by cold call or mass email.
In a category this crowded, the people doing good work don't need to interrupt you.

The one thing worth understanding about AI and your business

45% of consumers now ask AI for local recommendations. But 88% then check the sources, and 97% go and verify on review platforms before they call. Meanwhile ChatGPT sends local businesses roughly 2% of the traffic Google does.

So AI is deciding who gets on the shortlist. Your reviews, your photos and how fast you answer decide who gets the job.

Anyone selling you AI traffic in 2026 is selling a number that doesn't exist yet. Anyone ignoring AI completely is leaving you off the shortlist. Both are getting it wrong, in opposite directions.

Sources

  • Whitespark 2026 Local Search Ranking Factors (47 experts, 187 factors)
  • BrightLocal Local Consumer Review Survey 2026 (1,002 US consumers)
  • BrightLocal LCRS AI module, March 2026 (455 AI users)
  • Sterling Sky, The State of Local SEO 2026
  • Google Search Central, AI Features and Your Website
  • Search Engine Land, July 2025, on llms.txt

Last updated . The numbers here come from surveys that get rerun every year, so I revisit this page when new ones land.

Every claim here is checkable. If you think I've got one wrong, tell me, and if you're right I'll correct it.

Scored low and don't fancy the weekend?

This is the work I do: the fast website, the Google Business Profile, the pages per service, the review system. Tell me your score and which items came out red, and I'll tell you what I'd fix first.